Back to Green Integer Review

Claudio Magris


To Have Been: A Dramatic Monologue

Translated from the Italian by Paul Vangelisti


††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††† ††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††††† ††††††† To Luca Doninelli



†††† And so Jerry is dead, never mind, that isnít the problem, neither for him nor anyone else, not even for me who loved him and still love him, because love doesnít conjugateómy God, in that sense, of course, whatís next, though love has its grammar and doesnít know tenses only verbal moods, in fact, just one, the present infinitive, when you love itís forever and the rest doesnít matter. Any love, any kind of love. Itís not true that you get over it, nothing goes away, and this is often the particular rub, but you carry it along with you, like life, and even that is not really such great luck, except that you get over love even less than life. Itís there, like starlight, who gives a damn if they are alive or dead, they shine and thatís that, and though in the daytime you canít see them but you know they are there.

†††† So we wonít hear that guitar anymore, and thatís fine too, you can learn to get along without anything. God, how he could play. And when his hand didnít work anymore, he pulled down the blinds and kissed it all goodbye. I have no objection to that. Sooner or later it happens, and it doesnít matter much how, anyway it has to happen, and who knows how many of us here this evening, ladies and gentlemen, will be alive in a monthís time, certainly not everybody, itís statistically impossible. Someone who is pushing his neighbor or complaining because the person in front of him is blocking his view of the stage has already gone to the barber for the last time, but never mind, a year more or less doesnít make much difference, I donít feel bad for those who kick the bucket and I donít envy those who keep on going, nor do I care much to know what group I fall into.

†††† Amen for Jerry, and for everybody and everything. As I said, I canít find fault with his decision, when someone wants to get off the bus, itís his right to get off, and if he prefers to jump off while itís still moving, before the stop, thatís his business. Someone can be fed up, tired, unable to take it anymore, what do I know. When seeing him down like that because he couldnít play as before, to cheer him up I told him that he had been one of the greats of the guitar, and he said that for him it wasnít enough to have been. He wanted to beóit didnít matter what, a musician, a lover, anything, but to be.

†††† Yes, ladies and gentlemen, in that moment I understood what great luck it is to be born like me, or to have an uncle or grandfather or whomever, born in Bratislava or LwÚw or Kaloea or in any other dump in this shabby Central Europe, which is a hell, a real cesspool. Itís enough to smell that musty odor, that stink which is the same from Vienna to Czernowitz, but at least it doesnít force you to be, on the contrary. Yes, if Jerry had understood, when his hand didnít work anymore, his great luck in having been, the freedom, the vacation, the great privilege of not having to be anymore, of not having to play anymore, his free pass from the barracks of life!

†† But maybe he couldnít, since he wasnít born or raised in that stagnant Pannonian air, thick as a blanket, in that smoke-filled tavern where you eat badly and drink even worse, but are happy to be there when itís raining outside and the wind is howlingóand outside, in life, itís always raining and the wind cuts through you. Yes, any grocer in Nitra or Varaědin could teach all of Fifth Avenueóexcept for those maybe who come from Nitra or Varaědin or some other place in those partsóthe happiness of having been.

††††† Oh, the modesty, the lightness of having been, that uncertain and accommodating space where everything is as light as a feather, against the presumption, the weight, the squalor, the freight of being! Please, Iím not talking about any kind of past and even less about nostalgia, which is stupid and hurtful, as the world itself says, nostalgia, the pain of returning. The past is horrific, we are barbaric and evil, but our grandparents and great-grandparents were even fiercer savages. I certainly wouldnít want to be, to live in their time. No, Iím saying that I would want to have always already been, exempt from the military service of existing. A slight disability is sometimes a way out, protecting you from the obligation of joining in and losing your skin.

†††† Being hurts, it doesnít let up. Do this, do that, work, struggle, win, fall in love, be happy, you must be happy, living is this duty to be happy, if youíre not how shameful. So, you do all you can to obey, to be as good and clever and happy as you ought, but how can you, things just fall on top of you, love smacks you on the head like a chunk of masonry off a roof, a wicked punch or worse. You walk hugging the walls to avoid those crazy cars, but the walls are crumbling, sharp rock and glass slicing your skin and making you bleed, you are in bed with someone and for an instant you understand what real life could and should be and it is an unbearable pangópicking your clothes off the floor, getting dressed, getting out and way. Luckily thereís a bar nearby, how good a coffee or a beer tastes.

†††† Yes, drinking a beer, for instance, is a way of having been. Youíre there, sitting down, you look at the foam evaporating, a little bubble every second, a heartbeat, one beat less, rest and the promise of rest for your tired heart; everything is behind you. I remember that my grandmother, when we went to visit her in Szabadka, would cover the sharp corners of the furniture with cloths and put away the iron table, so that we children wouldnít get hurt when we ran into something racing around the house, and she would even cover the electric plugs. To have been is this, living in this space where there are no sharp corners; you donít scrape your knee, you canít turn on the lamp that hurts your eyes, all is quiet, time out, no ambush.

†††† So, ladies and gentlemen, this is the heritage that Central Europe has left us. A safe-deposit box, empty but with a lock on it to keep out bank robbers who might want to put who knows what inside it. Empty, nothing that grabs your heart and bites into your soul, life is there, already been, secure, safe from any accident, an out-of-circulation bank note for a hundred old crowns that you hang on the wall, under glass, with no fear of inflation. Even in a novel, the best part, at least for the writer, is the epilogue. Everything has already happened, been written, worked out; the characters live happily ever after or are dead, itís all the same, in any case nothing more can happen. The writer holds the epilogue in his hands, rereads it, maybe he changes a comma, but he runs no risk.

†††† Every epilogue is happy, because itís an epilogue. You go out on the balcony, a breeze comes through the geraniums and the violets of thought, a drop of rain slides down your face; if it rains harder you like to listen to the drumming of the fat drops on the awning. When it stops you go take a little stroll, you exchange a few words with the neighbor you meet on the stairs; neither for him nor you does it matter whatís said, itís just a pleasure to hesitate there a moment and from the window on the landing you can see way down there in the distance a strip of sea that the sun, now out from behind the clouds, lights up like a knife blade. Next week weíre going to Florence, your neighbor says. O yes, itís nice, Iíve been there. And in this way you save yourself the fuss of traveling, the lines, the heat, the crowds, looking for a restaurant. A stroll in the evening air fresh with rain, then back home. You must not wear yourself out, otherwise youíll get too excited and sleep wonít come. Insomnia, ladies and gentlemen, believe me, is a terrible thing. It crushes you, suffocates you, follows at your heels, chases you, poisons youóyes, insomnia is the supreme form of beingóinsomnia, thatís why you have to sleep, sleeping is the only antechamber of the true having already been, but meanwhile itís already something, a sigh of reliefÖ



Italian novelist, essayist, cultural philosopher, and professor of German literature, Claudio Magris was born in Trieste in 1939. Among his many novels and other writings are Danube and Micrososms, both published in English. He has been mentioned as a contender for the Nobel Prize in Literature several times. In 2007, Green Integer will publish three plays by Magris, including the monologue above.


English language copyright ©2006 by Paul Vangelisti and Green Integer.